Thoughts on abortion

I have been following the American election campaigns and the abortion issue is always on the table when politics are debated. Not so much right now though, as the immigration issue is mainly in focus. However, the idea of allowing after-birth abortion has been vented and it stuck in my mind, so I had to do some further research and reflections. 

 In the Netherlands it's legal to use euthanasia on newborn infants, when there is risk for unbearable suffering for the child. This may seem grotesque and savage, but is justified as an act of mercy, to spare someone of a life not worth living. In the article 'After-birth abortion, why should the baby live? from 2013, Alberto Guiblini and Francesca Minerva takes it a step further and suggests that the potential suffering of the parents and society should be reason enough to kill an infant after birth, even if it's fully healthy.  "Indeed, however weak the interests of actual people can be, they will always trump the alleged interest of potential people to become actual ones, because this latter interest amounts to zero." (Giublini & Minerva, 2013). 

Guiblini & Minerva are basing their arguments on the assumption that fetuses and infants lack any aim and only are capable of experiencing either pain or pleasure. They mean that infants are not yet people, they are not persons or individuals with right to their own lives and are to be valued the same as fetuses.  They even suggest that after-birth abortion could be preferred over adoption if the potential suffering of the birth mother would be worse if the child was given up for adoption, or if the child potentially would be a burden to society or the economic situation of the parents.  

Giublini & Minerva (2013) suggest that after-birth abortion should not have any set time threshold : " First, we do not put forward any claim about the moment at which after-birth abortion would no longer be permissible, and we do not think that in fact more than a few days would be necessary for doctors to detect any abnormality in the child. In cases where the after-birth abortion were requested for non-medical reasons, we do not suggest any threshold, as it depends on the neurological development of newborns, which is something neurologists and psychologists would be able to assess."

 To not have a time threshold in combination with capricious definitions of what determines a person,  and what determines suffering could in the long run escalate into a society where it is legal to assassinate children, or even adults, at any age, if they are deemed a burden to society, are not considered persons of value, or perceived as suffering beyond that is considered a life worth living. In America they already have the death penalty for criminals, so perhaps the step towards after-birth abortion is not that difficult for them. 

My personal opinion on the matter is that when there is fetal viability abortion should not be legal and definitely not after-birth abortion. That is how I value and respect life in this context. I also don't think it's fair to base decisions regarding life and death on loose assumptions of what constitutes a person. Giublini & Minerva places greater value on "non-human animals" as persons than infants.  I love animals and see them as persons too, but to use that as an argument to devalue infants does not land right even in my world. Human and non-human animals have souls too. 

What are your thoughts? Please comment. 

Peace & Love

Angelina

Soruces: 

https://www.npr.org/2024/09/10/nx-s1-5107942/abortion-roe-wade-ivf-donald-trump-kamala-harris-debate-2024

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fetal_viability

Giubilini AMinerva F. (2013). 
After-birth abortion: why should the baby live?.

Comments

Labels

design9 life9 ethics8 illustrations8 culture7 pandemic7 politics7 space7 angelina6 climate change6 crisis communication6 education6 elander6 face masks6 mars6 prints6 surrealism6 feminism5 fun5 learning5 social distancing5 Ukraine4 animal rights4 animals4 conspiracy theories4 driving4 future4 hobbies4 interpretation4 media4 peace4 racism4 research4 vaccine4 war4 TikTok3 artist3 family3 film3 human rights3 nature3 population3 psychology3 reality3 star trek3 studies3 ufo3 watercolor3 writing3 502 AI2 Christmas2 Facebook2 Instagram2 Russia2 Spotify2 age2 aliens2 ancient civilizations2 artemis2 beliefs2 camera effects2 cars2 celebrity2 china2 composer2 documentary2 drivers license2 easter2 electricity2 esc2 eurovision song contest2 fitness2 gender equality2 global warming2 globalism2 identity2 insights2 issues management2 logo2 mass hypnosis2 melodifestivalen2 musician2 mysticism2 noice2 numerology2 opportunity2 power2 profit2 psychoanalysis2 reels2 release2 religion2 society2 south africa2 space exploration2 spacetravel2 speech2 summer2 terraforming2 training2 vegan2 worldview2 America1 Apple1 Audition1 Australia1 COP271 Cern1 Cubase1 Google1 Grusch1 Guiblini1 Harris1 ISS1 Italy1 Jung1 Lithuania1 Matrix1 Maya1 Minverva1 NATO1 Prime Minister1 Putin1 Rebirth1 Shangri-La1 Singapore1 Sun1 Trump1 Twitter1 UK1 WHO1 Wargames1 Yamaha1 YouTube1 Zelenskyj1 abortion1 abstract1 acrylics1 adventure1 ageism1 angelinaelander1 animal extinction1 animal rescue1 annunaki1 antipsychotic drugs1 aqaurelle1 artificial intelligence1 asian1 asmr1 astronaut1 backyard1 ballet1 behavior1 belief1 berries1 birthday1 body language1 borg1 cancel culture1 canvas1 cats1 chat gpt1 chatbots1 chemistry1 children1 civilization1 climate debate environment climate change Jordan Peterson Alex Epstein nihilism overpopulation fossil fuels1 climate debate environment climate change Jordan Peterson fossil fuels1 collage1 compulsive speaking1 computer1 concentration1 conflict management1 conscience1 copyright1 coronation1 country1 cover art1 covid1 creatures1 criminality1 damaskus1 davinci plus1 debate1 decade1 desing1 diet1 discussion1 dune1 ecology1 environment angelina elander1 environmental awareness1 environmentalism1 exploration1 feelings1 filters1 fires1 flat earth1 focus1 food1 football1 framgment1 friendship1 games1 glitches1 goat1 greta van fleet1 guns1 gym1 haircolor1 halloween1 hands1 hasse carlsson1 heat1 history1 humanity1 iTunes1 id1 illustration1 inflation1 instrumental1 intelligence1 interview1 invasion1 iran1 jacket1 jarmusch1 joaquin1 job application1 joker1 journal1 karma1 kings1 lastwords1 lifestyle1 linguistics1 livestock1 loab1 lounge1 love1 mask1 mathematics1 meat industry1 medicine1 medium1 memory1 mers1 moods1 moon1 morale1 motives1 mystery1 mythology1 nasa1 nerding1 new1 new age1 news1 nibiru1 november1 omicron vaccine1 oscars1 overpopulation1 overview effect1 paint1 paintings1 palidrome1 parents1 passport1 patriarchy1 personal1 personal development1 personality disorders1 phenomenon1 philosophy1 phoenix1 pi1 picard1 pigs1 pizzazz1 popular culture1 posts1 poverty1 power structures1 primitive civilization1 publication1 quantum entanglement1 queens1 radical activism1 reading1 relations1 religions1 rhetoric1 rover1 royalties1 sars1 science1 science fiction1 selflove1 sentience1 shame1 silence1 simpson1 simulations1 snaps1 snow1 social media1 solution1 soul1 spacecraft1 spirit1 spiritual1 spyware1 strategy1 study1 support1 survival1 sushi1 swimsuit1 synchronicities1 technology1 test1 the world1 theater1 thruthers1 tiger1 tik tok1 time1 tracks1 trademark1 tradition1 traffic1 travel1 twin peaks1 twosday1 vacation1 values1 vampire. noir1 venus1 veritas1 videos1 virtual reality1 vocals1 weapon industry1 weather1 wikipedia1 wildlife conservation1 winner1 winter1 work1 workout1 world of warcraft1 zebra1 zlatan ibrahimovic1 zombies1
Show more